Saturday, June 19, 2010

Scenes From MainEA


Call it MEAMaine, or MainEA, but our Eleventh Annual Media Ecology Association Convention held on June 10-13 was a great success, thanks to our gracious hosts, the University of Maine at Orono, and convention coordinators Paul Grosswiler and Ellen Rose.

Here now are some scenes from the event, and I hope you'll forgive me for mainly picking out the ones that feature me, but you may recall that I I have said on a number of occasions that this blog is mainly an exercise in narcissism.  And the rest of the pictures are available through the MEA website, if you want a more complete picture (and see also the Picassa web album for the event).

First off, here are some photographs from our program session on general semantics, as I was presenting my paper:






















































That last one wasn't too bad, I think, but you know I show these to you, warts and all.  Anyway, this particular session, which was chaired by Jackie Rudig, and also featured a paper by Geri Forsberg, and was supposed to include Corey Anton as well.  Unfortunately, Corey couldn't make it, but he was able to use Skype to present his paper from home, and that too was captured by our intrepid photographer, Octavio Islas:













See, that's Corey up on the big screen.  And you can also see a bit of the audience, and here's another view of them, taken while I was giving my talk:












And from another angle:



Of course, I was in the audience for other sessions, and here you can see me paying rapt attention:



Okay, busted, I was checked my tweets!  But I am able to multitask, you know?  Seated on my left is Geri Forsberg, by the way.   And no, I wasn't doing that constantly, look:



Anyway, later that day, I introduced Nora Bateson, daughter of Gregory Bateson, who previewed her outstanding, absolutely briliant documentary about her father, An Ecology of Mind.  I didn't find any pictures of that program, but here's a photograph of Nora taken during a break time--she's the one on the left:



And that evening, I introduced her sister, Mary Catherine Bateson (daughter of Gregory and Margaret Mead), who gave a featured presentation.  Here I am singing Mary Catherine's praises, followed by Dr. Bateson delivering her illuminating address:

The next two photos come from Facebook, courtesy of Peter Fallon, from a session that I chaired and he presented on, along with Geri Forsberg again, and Jerry Harp via Skype.  Peter is on the left, and Ed Tywoniak, rendering technical assistance, on my the right:

 

 



And here I am that evening, presenting the 2010 MEA Awards. Among the individuals that we honored were Mary Catherine Bateson, who received the MEA's Neil Postman Award for Outstanding Career Achievement in Public Intellectual Activity, and Don Ihde, recipient of the MEA's Walter Ong Award for Outstanding Career Achievement in Scholarship.

And here's a shot of our most excellent host and technomeister, Paul Grosswiler, in action:



And finally, speaking of our host, here is some ambiance, atmosphere, environment and ecology of this outstanding event:






 





 


And  after all, there is nothing like an MEA Convention, nothing in this world, at least!




Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Notes on Teaching General Semantics


In a recent post, Promoting Health, Media Ecology Style, I posted the outline notes for a presentation I made at the recent MEA meeting, and I have to confess that I am not usually in the habit of making presentations based on formal outlines, although this is the typical method taught in public speaking courses across the USA.  

As a media ecology doctoral student, Neil Postman impressed upon me that the best way to prepare a formal presentation is to write everything out, writing for the ear, but having it all in front of you.  That doesn't mean reading from the paper and never looking up, however, as he also stressed the need to practice and prepare, so that all you need to do is glance down at the paper, and then back at the audience as you deliver your address.  This is, in fact, the method that politicians and officials often use, or used before the advent of transparent screens on which speeches could be projected, so the speaker need never look down.

So, for me, when I have a formal presentation, I usually follow the Postman method.  In other instances, say on a roundtable discussion, I will just jot down some informal notes, or maybe just speak off the top of my head.  But I did use formal outlines for many years when I started out teaching classes at Fordham University and elsewhere, and I had occasion to return to some of my old notes before the MEA convention, which put the idea in my head and prompted me to create a formal outline for my presentation on health and media ecology.

The reason for my return to my old lecture notes is also connected to the MEA convention, as I was asked to prepare a handout on teaching general semantics for the event. which I did.   I don't claim that they're anything special, many others teach the same topics in the same way as I do, but the handout could possibly be helpful to someone in some way, so for that reason I was happy to share it with folks at MEA, I understand it's also going to be distributed via the Institute of General Semantics website, and I am also pleased to be able to share it with you here on my blog (and hey, if nothing else, it gives me another blog post if you know what I mean).  So, here it is:


Lance Strate’s Lecture Notes on Teaching General Semantics
Prepared for Distribution at the 11th Annual Convention of the Media Ecology Association
University of Maine, Orono, ME, June 10-13, 2010


Martin Levinson, President of the Institute of General Semantics, asked that I share my lecture notes for teaching general semantics, and I am happy to do so.  For many years, I taught a basic course introducing students to the field of communication.  These courses are known by many names, Introduction to Communication (Theory/Studies), Process of Communication, Perspectives on Communication, Concepts of Communication, etc.  My approach has been to present general semantics on its own terms, as a separate topic and unit.  I should note that my approach to teaching general semantics in this context has also been to build upon material covered in other units, and otherwise point out interconnections with topics such as perception, rhetoric, linguistics (including Sapir-Whorf and Vygotsky), semiotics and symbolic communication, metaphor, symbolic interaction, information theory and cybernetics, systems theory, and of course, media ecology, but that has varied over the years, and across different contexts, and is an option, not a requirement.  In addition to the readings listed below, these notes are drawn, in part, on graduate courses I took with Neil Postman and Christine Nystrom in the late, lamented Media Ecology Program at New York University, and also on undergraduate courses I took with Jack Barwind as an undergraduate Communication Arts major at Cornell University.  Some modifications have been made to the notes over the years, and in the course of preparing them for distribution in this form.

For those looking to familiarize themselves with general semantics, or deepen their understanding, here are some recommendations.  Wendell Johnson’s classic work, People in Quandaries, was the required text in general semantics in Neil Postman’s doctoral program in media ecology, providing a comprehensive, well organized, and clearly written discussion (albeit with some dated material on stuttering and other therapeutical issues at the end).  Postman also used Harry Weinberg’s Levels of Knowing and Existence, which he used when he covered general semantics in a graduate class on Language and Human Behavior.  Both of these works can be purchased through the IGS, as can many other fine works in this area, more than I can mention here, including Korzybski’s original works such as Science and Sanity, and Kenneth Johnson’s Outline Survey of general semantics, which I would highly recommend as a concise summary of the field.  Also of particular interest in an educational context would be two anthologies edited by Mary Morain, Teaching General Semantics: A Collection of Lesson Plans for College and Adult Classes, and Classroom Exercises in General Semantics.  In preparing these lecture notes, in addition to People in QuandariesLevels of Knowing and Existence, I have drawn upon two works that are sadly out of print, John C. Condon’s short book, Semantics and Communication, and Postman’s own work, Crazy Talk, Stupid Talk, which is based in part on People in Quandaries, advances many of the ideas, and provides an important bridge to media ecology. and



General Semantics


I.    Founded by Alfred Korzybski
A.    Korzybski was a Polish engineer who immigrated to the US, and was motivated by experiences in WWI
B.    War—communication problem
C.    When engineers get together to build a bridge, they have no problems understanding each other or getting the job done. Why shouldn’t peace be as easy to build as a bridge?
D.    Language of science was the key, and general semantics founded on idea of scientific language.  As one prominent general semanticist, Wendell Johnson, a professor of speech pathology, put it, “The language of science is the better part of the method of science.”
E.    A product of early 20th century faith in science and progress, and continued appeal to American pragmatism
F.    Highly influential in mid-20th century, proponents include S. I. Hayakawa (US Senator), Wendell Johnson (and his son Nicholas, former FCC Commissioner), Stuart Chase (economist highly influential in FDR’s New Deal), William S. Burroughs (novelist), A. E. van Vogt (sf writer, Alien), Robert Heinlein (sf writer, Stranger in a Strange Land), Frank Herbert (sf writer, Dune), Robert Anton Wilson (sf and nonfiction writer), L. Ron Hubbard (dianetics and scientology), Albert Ellis (rational emotive behavior therapy), Richard Bandler (neuro-linguistic programming), and many more
G.    More close to home, had influence on Kenneth Burke (rhetoric), Gregory Bateson (anthropology), Buckminster Fuller (design), French poststructuralists such as Derrida and Foucault, German sociologists such as Niklas Luhman, communication theorists such as Irving Lee, Elwood Murray, Tom Pace
H.    Favorable mentions from Mumford, McLuhan.  Foundational to the media ecology of Neil Postman, who edited ETC:  A Review of General Semantics, for a decade.  Pervades much of his early, collaborative work, and his important book, Crazy Talk, Stupid Talk.  An ecological approach, Korzybski described it as an “organism-as-a-whole-in-an-environment” perspective, and also makes reference to neuro-linguistic environments, neuro-semantic, and simply, semantic environments (the latter used by Wendell Johnson and Neil Postman). General semantics and the non-Aristotelian approach represents a response to the postliterate, electronic culture that has been emerging over the past century, Aristotelian thinking being a product of writing, literacy, and the alphabet.

II.    From a scientific point of view, energy is fundamental
A.    Laws of thermodynamics, Einstein’s E=MC2
B.    Energy is fundamental substance of the universe
C.    Matter is a form of energy
D.    Energy is dynamic, not static; event, not thing
E.    All forms of life based on energy
F.    Categorized into 3 classes of life based on use of energy
1.    Chemistry-Binding—plants, completely dependent on chemical processes, photosynthesis for life
2.    Space-Binding—animals, ability to move around on their own
3.    Time-Binding—humans, transmit knowledge over time, make progress. “If I can see farther, it is because I am standing on the shoulders of giants.” (Newton).  Knowledge is power, energy, most of which we inherit from previous generations
a.    progress through time-binding most apparent in science and technology—geometric advances
b.    progress in ethics, politics, economics, social and human relations, much slower—arithmetic advances
c.    given the superiority of science and technology in making progress, other sectors of society need to become more scientific in their thinking and communication
d.    scientific method, empiricism, reality-testing, use of precise language is essential

III.    Following Einstein’s non-Newtonian physics, and non-Euclidean geometry, Korzybski proposes a non-Aristotelian mode of thought and communication
A.    Not anti-Aristotle, but post-Aristotle
B.    Aristotelian Laws of Thought (rules of logic)
1.    Aristotle codified basic rules of logic, which we take for granted, seems natural to us
2.    Law of identity. A=A. A thing is what it is. A man is a man, truth is truth. A is always A; A is all A
3.    Law of excluded middle. A=B or AB, either/or. Either a man or not a man, either the truth or not the truth
4.    Law of non-contradiction. Not A=B AND AB. Not both a man and not a man, not both the truth and not the truth
5.    Laws implies permanence, static relationship, polarization, things are discrete, not process. Allows us to categorize things (no double counting to confuse inventories).
C.    Korzybki’s Non-Aristotelian Principles of Thought
1.    Principle of Non-Identity—A is not A. No identity relationships in nature. A map is not the territory it represents. The word is not the thing it represents. Whatever you say a thing is, it is not.
a.    Korzybski sat on a chair and it broke, hence a chair is not a chair.  Money is money--$100 check vs. $100 cash. Different attitudes towards money in rich, see it as symbol, not thing. Spinal tap amp “11.” Taboo words, curse words, bigot words, Lenny Bruce, body and sex words, death, disease—cancer; euphemisms
b.    Korzybski/IGS seminars.  Give out biscuits, people eat them, no problem, then show box of dog biscuits, some people feel sick, reacting to symbol or reality?  Same with chocolate/chocolate covered ants.  Cultural/symbolic prohibitions about food, kosher laws, insects (perfectly fine to eat, survival training), shell fish as insects of the sea.  Scenes from Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom, Survivor reality TV series.
c.    Would you feel uncomfortable about drawing a mustache on a picture of your mother? Taking a pin and poking out the eyes?
2.    Principle of Non-Allness—A is not all A. By labeling, we leave out information. A writer, fine, also a criminal.
a.    A map does not represent all of a territory. Words do not say all there is to say about the things they represent. A person cannot say all there is to say about a thing. The word “is” does no mean “equals.” Johnny is bad.
b.    Danger of absolutism, universalism
3.    Principle of self-reflexiveness. An ideal map would include a map of a map, etc. It is possible to speak words about words, and words about those words, etc. It is possible to react to one’s reactions, react to those reactions, etc. Statements about statements, evaluations of evaluations. Metacommunication, recursion.
a.    Ask—describe what you are doing right now. Like mirror reflecting mirror. Infinite. Mead, consciousness and self-consciousness, imagine self as object, as others see us, and as we see them, etc. Carlyle, man is not unique because he uses tools, animals use tools. Man is unique because he uses tools to make tools. We use machines to answer and watch other machines. (VCR taping and not watching)
b.    Source of paradox.  Barber shaves every man in the village who doesn’t shave himself, who shave the barber?  To every rule there is an exception (as a rule itself).  This statement is false.
c.    Whitehead and Russell, Theory of Logical Types, class cannot be a member of itself
d.    Gödel, Incompleteness Theorem
e.    Hofstadter, Gödel, Escher, Bach; self-reflexiveness as basis of consciousness (self-consciousness)

IV.    Abstracting
A.    Key concept in general semantics
B.    Verb indicates process, as opposed to abstraction as a thing
C.    Understood in terms of levels or orders of abstracting
D.    Models:  Korzybski, Structural Differential; Hayakawa, simpler, more accessible ladder model
E.    Concept of abstracting unites perception and language/symbolic communication
F.    Levels of abstraction
1.    Event level, the reality we can never entirely know, where every phenomenon is a unique event in spacetime, no identity relationships in nature
2.    Object level, perception, organize chaotic sensory data, establish continuities, memory, recognition as basic form of identity
3.    Verbal levels, assign unique name, establishing identity over time; higher levels involve categorization
a.    Example:  Neighbor’s dog, Shirley. Shirley exists on the event level, out there in reality. 
b.    On the object level I know Shirley as a series of encounters, separate experiences, that I relate to one another.
c.    In giving these experiences a name, Shirley, I tie the experiences together to form a single identity, Shirley, as an unique individual.
d.    When I say that Shirley is a poodle, the world “poodle” here refers to a class of individuals, a category. All categories only exist in our minds. There may be a physical basis for our creation of the category, but first we must perceive and make the distinction. This is why we call such a category an abstraction, and place poodle on the second verbal level of abstracting. I may then say that a poodle is a kind of dog, and we place dog on the third level. I can go on to say that a dog is a mammal, an animal, a living thing, etc., moving higher and higher up in level of abstracting.
G.    Abstracting is a process of leaving out details, as we proceed from lower to higher levels, more details are left out
H.    Abstracting is a process of categorization, in leaving out more and more details, we put the phenomenon into categories or classes that are increasingly more general.  This is stereotyping, and one of the great successes of general semantics in the 20th century has been its contributions to educational efforts concerning stereotyping, prejudice, and scapegoating.
I.    Abstracting is a personal, subjective process where we project our evaluations onto reality. Instead of saying Shirley is a poodle, I could say that Shirley is a female.  Ask, who feels hot, who feels cold, who feels cold.  Differences in categorizing coffee as hot, pizza. Experiment:  put left hand in bucket, 35 degrees, right in 140 degrees, then both in 70 degrees. Left feels warm or hot, right feels cool or cold.
J.    The same words can have different meanings corresponding to different levels of abstracting.  This is called multiordinality.  For examples, the chair, in reference to one specific chair is on a lower level of abstracting than a chair, referring to the entire class of chairs.

V.    General Semantics Recommends
A.    Cultivate consciousness of abstracting, be aware of the process (consciousness raising).
B.    Employ an extensional orientation (inductive, gather data, check facts) rather than an intensional orientation (deductive, work off of assumptions, figure things out in your head without bothering to check).
C.    Employ a mutli-valued orientation rather than a two-valued orientation (shades of gray rather than black or white, dimmer switch rather than on or off, more than two sides to every issue).
D.    Avoid elementalism.  General semantics is a holistic, ecological approach, cautions against the way that words can separate phenomena that in reality cannot be separated, for example, space and time, mind and body, intellect and emotion.
E.    Don’t use allness words: always, never, nothing, nobody, everybody, everything, entirely, absolutely, of course, etc. (never say never).
F.    Deal in probabilities, not absolutes, use qualifying terms (probably, it seems to me, in my opinion, based on my previous experience, to the best of my recollection).
G.    Be conscious of your semantic reactions, and try to employ symbol reactions (reflective, delayed, mindful), rather than signal reactions (reflexive, immediate, kneejerk).  Traditional wisdom:  Look before you leap, count to ten, don’t count your chickens, stop, look, and listen.  Remember that there is always uncertainty, so don’t prejudge—check it out!
H.    Pavlov’s dogs. Dogs are not so bright, employ signal reactions. We need to delay reactions in order to make each reaction appropriate to the particular thing we are reacting to.
I.    Election, propaganda. React like Pavlov’s dogs to such words as abortion, welfare, taxes, inflation, war, peace.  General semantics has made significant contributions to the study, analysis, and criticism of persuasion and propaganda.
J.    Wendell Johnson, “To a mouse, cheese is cheese. That is why mouse traps are effective. To many humans being Right is Right, Wrong is Wong, Capital is Capital, and Labor is Labor. That is why propaganda is effective.”

VI.    Language and Extensional Devices
A.    Korzybski advocated the use of visual images because they are more concrete and specific than words, and favored mathematics because it is more flexible and less ambiguous than words.
B.    While general semantics typically recommends avoiding high level abstractions, Wendell Johnson cautioned against dead level abstracting, that is, staying on the same level of abstracting, rather than moving up and down the levels.
C.    Problematic nature of the verb “to be” identified by Korzybski.  When Bill Clinton said, “it depends on what the meaning of is is,” it sounded like weasel words, and was not a good thing to say under the circumstances, but actually makes sense from a general semantics perspective.  Look up “is” in the dictionary.  Actually quite complex.  Two particular problems. 
1.    One is the “is” of projection, associated with adjectives. We project all of the adjective’s qualities onto the noun it is describing. If we say that Johnny is bad, we are saying that Johnny equals bad, and thus is all bad, always bad. Influenced child psychology, don’t say you are bad; better to say, you did a bad thing; better still to say, what you did made me angry.
2.    The other problem occurs from the use of the “is” of identification. We confuse the word “is” with the word equals, and identify one noun with another. We may say that one and one is two, but do we mean the same thing when we say Joe is a criminal?  That everything there is to say about Joe is summed up by saying he is a criminal, and that everything associated with the term criminal applies to Joe?
3.    Not a problem to use “to be” as an auxiliary verb (It is raining), or to indicate existence (I am, I am that I am)
4.    Some in general semantics try to eliminate the verb “to be” entirely. E-prime (English-prime), English without the verb “to be” (several anthologies published).  Difficult, but improves writing, nothing more boring than is—It is raining vs. The rain poured down.
D.    Korzybski and others proposed the use of several devices to remind us of the non-Aristotelian laws of thought.
1.    Indexing—What is an index in a book? Use indexing—apartment numbers, street address, zip code, phone numbers, social security numbers, drivers license numbers, cataloging in Library. Algebra: X1, X2
2.    Johnny1 is not Johnny2 (people are different in different situations).  Chair1 is not chair2 (one may be cushioned, the other not, size may vary, one may break and the other not). Time1 is not time2 (things change over time).
3.    Dating—newspapers, magazines, documents, letters. Joe1980 is not Joe2010. Joe may have been a criminal then, but he could change and be a professor of law now. $22010 does not equal $21960.
4.    Et cetera—By ending every statement with etc. we are reminded that we cannot say all there is to say about anything, that there’s always more to be said, always much that we’ve left out.
5.    Hyphens: Space-time, mind-body, emotional-intellectual, to indicate that the separate terms do not exist in isolation of one another in reality
6.    Quotes: “Emotional” maladjustment, “intellectual” achievement.  In speaking, use of quotation marks gesture
7.    Plurals—Effect similar to indexing: instead of asking what is the cause of war, lower the level of abstracting by asking what are the causes of wars.  Instead of talking about falling in love as one thing, talk about fallings in loves
8.    Quantifying terms: Don’t say hot, say 95 degrees, or 70 degrees (weatherman)
9.    Qualifying terms: State exceptions, specify conditions—except, but, under conditions of, in our culture, of our time, to me, in my opinion, as I see it, from my point of view, etc. Watergate—“to the best of my recollection.”

VII.    Reification
A.    It is possible to use words that do not refer to anything in reality. The most extreme example would be nonsense words like grib and jabberwocky.  Some words refer to things that were thought to exist, but in fact do not, like phlogiston and ether.
B.    Take id, ego, supergo. They are ideas that Freud used to try to describe the way people’s minds work. But they are not things that are present in reality. Examine the brain, can’t find the id, ego, superego.
C.    High level abstractions do not refer to “things” in reality, although they seem to.  The concept of the nation is an example.  We talk about nations as if they were real things, but there is no agreement on how to define “nation” or what constitutes a nation, no objective test to determine whether some entity is a nation.  Benedict Anderson: nations are imagined communities.  Social construction.
D.    Sometimes, words that seem to refer to something real can be dangerous.  An example of this is the word “race.” One general semanticist, the anthropologist Ashley Montagu, delivered a lecture on race to the American Association of Physical Anthropologists in 1941. He used genetics as his basis for condemning the use of the term “race” among anthropologists, arguing that it concepts of race are nothing more than a product of statistical averaging.  In fact, the definition of race differs from one culture to another (in the US we traditionally defined white vs. black on an all or nothing basis of purity, whereas other cultures in the western hemisphere have at least one category of mulatto, and Brazil had 3 different races in between the extremes of black and white), and one time period to another (in the 19th century, Italians, Greeks, Jews, etc., were not considered white, and it was common to use race interchangeably with ethnicity).
E.    A similar problem occurs with the use of the word “intelligence” by social and behavioral scientists. Because the word exists, we assume that the thing it refers to exists, and we try to find it, to describe it, to measure it, to test it.  We’re not sure what it is, but we come up with a test for it anyway.  And in the end we mistake the score on an intelligence test for intelligence itself. The score is real, intelligence is not. The score is merely a measure of an individual’s ability to take the test. Stephen Jay Gould, The Mismeasure of Man, has argued that intelligence testing has been used (perhaps unintentionally) to “prove” that white Americans are superior, in intelligence, to non-whites and immigrants.  People institutionalized for scoring a few points below the minimum legal requirement on intelligence tests, even though they are capable of taking care of themselves.  Howard Gardner, theory of multiple intelligences, extensional device of using plurals.
F.    Modern maps, north as up, top, arbitrary, ideological, vs. ancient orientation
G.    As we go higher up in levels of abstracting, we reach the point where there are words about words, and not things. But because the word exists, we believe that the thing must exist, we must thingify the word. This is called reification, to make real. When we try to find and measure abstractions like intelligence, patriotism, love, we are guilty of reification.

VIII.    Idealization and Operationalism
A.    Wendell Johnson believed that mistaking high-level abstractions for things often leads to the IFD disease. The IFD disease refers to the following process: Idealization. Frustration. Demoralization.
B.    For example, most people have the same goals: success, happiness, love, peace, fulfillment. Counselors and therapists are constantly finding patients who have been demoralized in their search for these goals, because they have idealized the terms, and therefore have no concrete indicators for having reached the goals.  Love is often idealized, so much so that no one seems to be good enough.
C.    Success is a good example.  Ask just about anyone who is a part of American culture if he or she wants to be a success, and he or she will say yes (indeed it’s an act of courage to say otherwise).  But how do you know when you are a success?  Therapists say that it’s not unusual to find people coming to them who are making a good living, their children are healthy, they have a summer home, their wives or husbands are agreeable, loving people, and yet, somehow there is something missing, something else, but they don’t know what it looks like or where it is. The problem is that they have idealized the word success. In idealizing success, you have placed it forever out of reach. This leads to frustration, and eventually to demoralization.  Take the even more basic example of rich.  Many people would like to be rich, but few think about how to determine if someone is rich or not.  What does it take to be rich? 
D.    The answer to this problem comes from science. Science teaches us that all terms must have operational definitions. Operational definitions are concrete definitions.  An experiment that calls for water specifies exactly what type of water is to be used, from what source (specific lake, river, rain), what type (distilled, demineralized, condensed steam), etc.  So, for example, if you say that being rich is having a million dollars in the bank, then your goal becomes measurable, and attainable.  When you reach the goal, you can feel a sense of satisfaction, pat yourself on the back.  You still can set new goals, of course, you don’t have to stop there. 
E.    If you say you want to be a rock star, operationalize it.  How would you define it.  Playing a concert for a certain number of people?  Releasing a recording?  A certain level of sales?  Signed by a label or going on tour?  Once you set a concrete goal, you can also outline the steps it would take to get there, the operations required to reach the goal.  This is how career counselors help people, by getting them to set goals, decide on whether they are realistic and obtainable (if not, you need to revise your goals), and then figure out the steps you need to get there.  This way, you have a plan to follow, and can also determine if you are not going to meet your goal and it’s best to move on.

IX.    Facts
A.    A fact is not so much a truth as it is a statement about truth.  Facts are commonly thought to be true, but actually are statements that can be proven true of false.
B.    A fact, is also know as a statement of fact, as a statement of description, and as a proposition (as in, this is proposed to be true).
C.     Scientific language uses propositions.  Simple statements of description are relatively low level abstracting, and can be proven true or false based on observation. “It is raining outside right now,” is a proposition. We can look out of the window or go outside and determine its validity.
D.    Generalizations represent a higher level of abstracting, for example, whenever dark clouds gather, rain follows.  We can test the generalization and see whether it holds true in this particular instance.  If it doesn’t, we have proven it false.  If it does, however, we have not proven it true, because we cannot text for every possible instance, past, present, and future.  Karl Popper.  All swans are white.
E.    No statement, no idea, no concept, no theory can be called scientific if it does not allow the possibility of being proven false.
F.    “He has $100,000 is a proposition, if we can gain access to the appropriate information, and prove it true or false. “He is rich,” is not a proposition, unless we give the word “rich” an operational definition that allows for testing.
G.    Not all statements are propositions.  Most are not.  Most statements cannot be proven true or false, or falsified.
H.    Truth in Advertising laws only go so far.  If the ad says the price is $100, and they charge you $200, that’s a false claim.  If the ad says the product does the job better than its competitor, and there is an objective test to determine whether that is so, the ad is factual, propositional.  If the ad says the product is cheaper and better, works faster, etc., without making a comparison, there is no statement that can be tested, therefore no false claim.  How can you prove true or false a statement like, “You’re in good hands with Allstate”; “Drivers wanted”; “I love New York”; or “Got milk?”
I.    Some statements are simply definitions, axioms, and in this sense tautolgies (it is what it is because I say it is).  Let x=3.  A dog is a four-legged mammal that barks.  A sentence is a complete thought.  You cannot prove a definition true or false, you can only accept or reject it.
J.    Some statements are judgments or opinions, expressing values and emotions.  He is evil is a value judgment, as opposed to saying he has been arrested and convicted of a crime.  Ethics and aesthetics are based on judgments.  You cannot prove that anything or anyone is bad or good, beautiful or ugly, etc.
K.    Some statements are inferences, which are assumptions (and what happens when you assume?).  They resemble propositions or facts, in that they are statements that could be proven true or false under the right conditions.  But they are deductions or leaps made without access to the need evidence.  I say it’s raining outside right now, there’s a window, so you look out and see that it is, that’s a proposition.  I say it’s raining outside right now, there’s no window, you know it was raining when you came in, so you figure it must still be raining, that’s an inference.
L.    Distinguishing Between Facts and Inferences
1.    Based on the information you have available to you right now, without further investigation, is the statement “I am standing here” a fact or an inference? Is the statement “I am wearing underwear” a fact or inference?
2.    In detective stories the hero finds clues and solves the crime by making inferences based on the clues.  Using inferences is a sign of intelligence, often tested for in grade school standardized tests for language/reading (which is the best title for this story?).  But distinguishing between facts and inferences is a more advanced form of intelligence, appears on IQ tests and LSATs.
3.    Exercise:  Fact/Inference Test
4.    Inferences are used in persuasion and propaganda.  Misleading association—actual association—implied association. Presidential candidate Adlai Stevenson worked in state department at the same time as Alger Hiss, who has been convicted of conspiring for communism. US corporation profits doubled in 1968, US casualties in Vietnam doubled in 1968.
5.    Inferences used in politics.  News leaks, background briefings, pseudo-events.  The president said, X.  This reporter was also told Y.
6.    News reporting, especially based on government or political sources, full of ambiguous language, suggesting inferences, but with deniability.
7.    Columnist has someone else do interview for him, write it in passive voice so he never says he asked the questions.
8.    General semantics, understanding of propositions and inferences, scientific approach, very useful for journalists, problem of objectivity similar to that in science, reporting the facts
9.    Images make no statements (Susanne Langer, Philosophy in a New Key), are not propositional or discursive, cannot be proven true or false.  The can be used as evidence to support a claim, but make no claim of their own.  As opposed to me saying, it is raining outside right now, if I show you a picture taken outside of rain, it makes no statement, it is what it is, a concrete image of a moment in time.  Only if I add the words, this is what it’s doing outside right now do we have a proposition.  A picture of a bombed out building can be accompanied by a caption that says it was a military target, or a civilian residence.  The same picture can be used to make contradictory statements, used by opposite sides.  That’s why we need to read the caption on an illustration, check the title card of a painting in an art museum.  The words tell us what we’re seeing.  Pictures are not worth a 1,000 words, not translatable, apples and oranges.  Case of Rodney King, first trial, prosecution let the video recording of the beating stand on its own, major mistake, as defense deconstructed the images.
10.    Ability to recognize the difference between facts and inference important in the legal sector, reading contracts, understand what they say, and what they don’t say
11.    Robert Heinlein in the science fiction novel Stranger In a Strange Land introduces the concept of the fair witness. A fair witness is a person who is specially trained to only report facts and make no inferences. For example, someone would ask a fair witness what color is that house. The fair witness would answer,” it is white on this side.”
12.    A colleague of mine served on a jury once, and got into an argument with her fellow jurors over a piece of evidence. The jurors all believe that the suspect was wearing a green army jacket. This evidence was based on a black and white photograph. The jurors could not distinguish between fact and inference, and this distinction is especially important in a trial.
13.    General semantics does not say “Never make an inference.” Inferences are a necessary part of our lives. What General Semantics does say is know the difference between an inference and a fact, and be aware of the fact that when you make an inference or an assumption, you may be making a mistake.

X.    Conclusion
A.    The major assumption of general semantics is that we have a constant need for a constant evaluation and constant re-evaluation because time is constantly flowing and change is constantly occurring.
B.    How we label things determines how we react to them. Power over how we label things is power over our reactions.
C.    The ability to change definitions, to not be tied to one definition, and also to be able to change levels of abstractions, is called reframing, and is an essential skill.
D.    Sanity, individually and most importantly collectively requires that we create and utilize maps that are as similar as possible to the environment that they represent.  Our maps may be subjective, and a product of social construction (intersubjectivity), but all maps are not alike, not equally valid or useful.  Some maps will leave us lost, others will allow us to arrive at our destination safe and sound.

Tuesday, June 15, 2010

Time Perspectives

In a previous post, Drawing on Motivation, I noted the unique "animate" cartooning style used by the RSA (the Royal Society for the encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce) in creating videos based on talks that they've sponsored.  Another one of these animates came to my attention courtesy of the media ecology listserv not too long ago, and since the theme of this piece is time, courtesy of Philip Zimbardo, a scholar well known in communication and behavioral science circles, it seems only fitting to include it here:





Perhaps "the secret powers of time" is a bit overly dramatic, but I think the piece is very nicely done.  The basic model of six time zones seems reasonable, consisting of paired dichotomies of past (positive and negative), present (hedonistic and fatalistic), and future (future oriented and transcendental).  And I particularly like the points Zimbardo makes about the role of language in the formation of attitudes, perspectives, and orientations towards time, as well as the influence of religion.  There is also an interesting point made about addiction being a "present hedonism" orientation.  And there is the very media ecological point about how we underestimate the power of technology to rewire our brains.


Under the same name, the RSA has made available a lecture of over forty minutes that was given by Zimbardo, from which the ten minute animate was taken:







It's interesting to see how they cut and edit this longer lecture to create the soundtrack for the animate.


As for the lecture itself, here, we see some interesting experimental work on the difference between present and future orientations, before he proceeds to add in the past, and then identify the dichotomies within each tense.  


Zimbardo is promoting a new book, The Time Paradox, which has its own website:  http://www.thetimeparadox.com.  And in case you're wondering, there actually are three paradoxes that are listed on the website:


Paradox 1
Time is one of the most powerful influences on our thoughts, feelings, and actions, yet we are usually totally unaware of the effect of time in our lives.

Paradox 2
Each specific attitude toward time—or time perspective—is associated with numerous benefits, yet in excess each is associated with even greater costs.

Paradox 3
Individual attitudes toward time are learned through personal experience, yet collectively attitudes toward time influence national destinies.

The topic of paradoxes also comes up in Zimbardo's six minute Ted Talk (boy this guy sure gets around):






This sure is a compressed and hurried version of the talks above.  The title given to this Ted Talk is Philip Zimbardo prescribes a healthy take on time, which brings in the theme of health, which you may recall was the topic of my last post (Promoting Health, Media Ecology Style).  Health in this instance is tantamount to balance among the various time orientations, and balance is very much an ecological value, don't you know?  


And that's all I have to say, until next time!







Monday, June 14, 2010

Promoting Health, Media Ecology Style

So, I've been away for the past several days at the Eleventh Annual Meeting of the Media Ecology Association, which was held at the University of Maine (and kudos to convention coordinators Paul Grosswiler and Ellen Rose for a wonderful event).

One of the sessions I participated on was called:  Media Ecology and Health Promotion in a U-Shaped World, and it was organized by David J. Waters.  David is Professor of Comparative Oncology and Associate Director of the Center on Aging and The Life Course at Purdue University, and since 2000, he has served as Executive Director of the Gerald P. Murphy Cancer Foundation, a not-for-profit research institute located in the Purdue Research Park.  David started the session off by presenting a paper entitled, “The Challenge of Promoting Health in a U-Shaped World,” and another David,
David E. Duncan of the BioAgenda Institute ended the session with a talk entitled, “Getting Health Messages Right: A Science Writer's Perspective,” both presentations being outstanding.

So, I was sandwiched in-between the two Davids, and with the title, “Getting Health Messages Right: A Media Ecologist's Perspective,” which was supplied by David Waters.  I started out by noting that the subject of health does not come up all that often in media ecology circles, but there is much that our field can offer to the study of health communication, and health and medicine.

I also mentioned my involvement in the AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety funded study of beer commercials, courtesy of Neil Postman, which was published as the research report, Myths, Men and Beer (by Neil Postman, Christine Nystrom, Lance Strate, and Charles Weingartner, 1987 which is still being distributed, for more information click here).  We recommended that beer ads be banned from television, a proposal that many in Congress were sympathetic to, and which led to all of the designated driver and "know when to say when" campaigns on the part of the beer industry.

I also noted that the assignment for the first year of the late, lamented media ecology doctoral program was to research the history of a medium or technology that was introduced prior to the 20th century, and a number of the students in the program chose medical technologies like the stethoscope, the thermometer, eyeglasses, etc., and I also draw on that work, as it was discussed in our classes.  Moreover, Postman devoted a chapter to medical technology in Technopoly, drawing in part on Ivan Illich's book, Medical Nemesis, and that's not to mention McLuhan's analysis of ads for aspirin and the like in The Mechanical Bride.
 
And of course I also noted my own experience as the parent of an autistic child, and the discussion that I include in my book, Echoes and Reflections: On Media Ecology as a Field of Study.

For my presentation, I prepared notes in an outline form, and I thought I'd share those notes here on Blog Time Passing, for what they're worth.  As notes, they don't provide complete and thorough explanations of the subject matter, but perhaps they might be of interest and use to someone out there. 


Getting Health Messages Right: A Media Ecologist's Perspective
Lance Strate

1.  Thinking About Health From a Media Ecology Perspective
A.  Body as a medium, as our primary medium, as the medium and mind the content 

B.  Medical intervention as altering the media environment, analogous to new medium, side effects as euphemism, undesirable, unanticipated, indirect, but real effects, Postman, Technopoly, iatrogenesis, e.g., prep for colonoscopy and kidneys
C.  Medium as language, body language, how does body talk to us, how do we talk about the body, e.g., as recently came up in general semantics circles, refer to symptoms as complaints; clients vs. patients; baby was in distress vs. baby almost died; negative patient care outcome as euphemism for death
D.  Relationships (Bateson systems perspective), how do I relate to my body, is it me or not me, a shell that I occupy, how do medical professionals relate to patients, as body or person, what kind of relationship, authority or guide?  

2.  Getting the Message Across

A.  Preventative messages hardest to get across, e.g., seatbelts, smoking (anti-smoking campaign initially increased desire to smoke);

B.  Henry Perkinson, No Safey in Numbers, computing leads to quantification of everything, leads to risk-aversive society.  Quantify risk, but how much is acceptable, we demand that risk be eliminated, but while reduction possible, elimination impossible.

C.  Risk only acceptable if it’s a matter of choice.  Anti-smoking campaign ineffective because smokers say, it’s my choice to take this risk.  Change came with second-hand smoke campaign, with victims who do not choose to take the risk, but are forced to.

D.  Tony Schwartz, The Responsive Chord, know your audience, don't test ads, test audiences

E.  Resonance, make message resonate with what audience already knows

F.  Broader sense, understand the culture, Diffusion of Innovations, Everett Rogers

G.  From media ecology perspective, to know the culture, have to know the media environment out of which the culture emerges

3.  Oral Cultures

A.  Oral traditions, collective memory

B.  Vast storehouse of knowledge about the environment, importance of botanical information for medicine

C.  Emphasis on the specific, not principles

D.  Except by analogy, Levi-Strauss, The Savage Mind, superstition, e.g., rhino horn and male potency

E.  Generally knowledge is shared and accessible, age important, limited specialization (medicine man or woman)

4.  Literate Cultures

A.  with writing comes accumulation of knowledge and specialization

B.  writing enhances abstract thinking, ability to make generalization and posit principles, but downside is stereotyping, ignoring the individual patient and only look at class, one size fits all, one drug cures all

C. writing also enhances analysis, able to focus on specific organs and systems and understand them better, but perhaps at expense holistic view of body as system

D.  ancient Greece, alphabet, 5th-4th c. BCE, Hippocrates, origin of medicine

E.  literacy limits access to knowledge, creates divisions between groups, specialization, Joshua Meyrowitz, No Sense of Place

F.  progress slow until 15th century printing revolution and knowledge explosion

G.  Elizabeth Eisenstein, The Printing Press as an Agent of Change in Early Modern Europe, tables, diagrams, illustrations; empiricism & publication, Modern Science

H.  Increasing volume of knowledge leads to increasing specialization

I.  With specialization come specialized language which further limits access

J.  High degree of separation between practitioner and client

K.  Need for schooling

L.  Innis, The Bias of Communication, Monopoly of knowledge

M.  Growth of professionalism

N.  Illich, Medical Nemesis, critique

5.  Visualism and Technology

A.  literacy and print lead to visualism, as opposed to orality based on sound

B.  visualism fosters objectivity, objectification

C.  body as object

D.  Cartesian dualism, mind/body, body is visual, mind is oral

E.  Shift from listening to patient to reading the body as text, through technology, visual and quantified

F.  Stethoscope (acoustic but treats body as thing), thermometer, other medical devices objectify, measure, and provide visual output

G.  surgery as visual examination; photography, X-rays, ultrasound (use sound to generate image)

H.  Eyeglasses, visual, extensions of man, body can be modified, not stuck with what nature gave you

I.  Medical technology and Jacques Ellul, Technological Society, technique as emphasis on efficiency, pills, drugs, as instant cure; Neil Postman, Technopoly

6.  Electronic media environment

A.  Reversal of print in some ways, extension in other ways (knowledge, specialization), creates a tension

B.  Dissatisfied with objectification of the body, want to be treated as a human being, whole person, holistic medicine

C.  Suspicious of monopoly of knowledge, which is weakened by accessibility of electronic media, from Dr. Kildare to WebMD

D.  Want second opinion, choice, agency, alternatives, alternative medicine, while still wanting efficiency

E.  Retrieval of oral culture, folk culture, homeopathic remedies, misinformation, can't just disprove, cultural problem

F.  General decline of authority (Meyrowitz, No Sense of Place), mystification and legitimation, suspicious of medical establishment, motives, profit, withholding treatment, conspiracy; iatrogenesis

G.  Example of vaccination and autism; fluoridation of water

7.  So what now?

A.  Medical professionals need to be honest about limits of their knowledge rather than invoke authority

B.  need to focus on human person rather than just body

C.  approach as relationship, partners

D.  make information accessible, do not withhold, example of conspiracy of silence regarding autism

E.  Neil Postman, Conscientious Objections, "Educationist as Painkiller," now, painkiller must be educationist, educate rather than inform and dictate

F.  people want choices, there are always choices, and they also want to know what is the most efficient of the choices

G.  Also need to focus on groups (peer groups, interest groups) rather than authority relationships with individuals, serve as guides, advisers

H.  Family group, workplace

I.  Social networks, in face-to-face situations, and online

J.  Social media, have to be a member of the group, not specialized professional on a pedestal


And that's about it.  I hope to be able to publish an essay on this topic in the future, time and tide willing. 

So until next time, my friends, stay healthy!

Monday, June 7, 2010

Zombie Text!

With this year's Media Ecology Association's annual convention just days away, it seems appropriate to put up a post relating to last year's MEA meeting, hosted by Saint Louis University.  At that time, I met Abigail Lambke, a doctoral student in their English Department, who was doing much of the heavy lifting in regard to local arrangements for our event.  I was therefore quite pleased to see that she published an article about Walter Ong, Saint Louis University's favorite son and one of the central figures in the field of media ecology.  It appeared in an online journal called FlowTV, or just plain Flow, and her piece was entitled A Walter Ong Artifact Travels Through Media, Time, and Meaning.

Be sure to click on the title and go read her article, but first, let me note that I was delighted to see her include a couple of short excerpts of a talk by Walter Ong in her article, courtesy of YouTube, and to see that she also has the a third video over on her YouTube channel that the two shorter segments were divided from.  So I'm please to be able to include it here, it's a short statement in Ong's own voice about the distinction between oral utterance and written text:







Thanks to Abigail for making this available to us!  The point Ong makes is incredibly resonant, I might add.  Speech is associated with the breath of life, text is a dead thing that only seems alive.  In other words, oh my goodness, text is a...   ZOMBIE!!!!!

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

Drawing on Motivation

In my previous post, Understanding the Comics Medium, I mentioned that Mike Plugh, who completed an outstanding MA thesis under my direction (meaning I got out of the way, and signed my name on it when it was done), and is about to embark on his doctoral work, brought Scott McCloud's TED talk to my attention.  And when he did, he first pointed out this other video to me, and suggested there was some similarity between the style of the cartoonist featured here, and McCloud's self-reflexive work on the comics medium.

So, for that reason alone, I'll share the video with you.  And I will admit that the cartooning styles have something in common, and also that this "animate" video does use, in its own way, the same kind of approach that McCloud shows us in the form of webcomics or digital comics.  That is, what we see is part of a larger picture, our screen is a frame that moves around within a larger frame.  

Of course, McCloud's examples are digital comics, whereas here we have someone drawing on a whiteboard (or sheet of paper) with markers, the camera following the drawing around as it progresses across and up and down the canvas, always showing us only part of the larger picture (in contrast to McCloud's examples where typically you can get an overview of the entire set of sequential images, also a feature of Prezi, an online alternative to PowerPoint that's worth a look, if you haven't seen it before).  

The cartooning footage has been edited to speed up the process, and synced to the lecture that we hear, this all occurring, presumably, after the fact, not while the lecture is going on.  I do seem to recall from long ago seeing this sort of cartooning being done live on television, with no editing, which was in a way more impressive, albeit less complex and instructive when done in that way.

This appears to be part of an "animate" series which seems to have a bit of a retro feel, at least insofar as I associate it with a kind of extemporaneous, jazz cartooning I recall seeing on TV long ago (and just the whole process of cartooning in this way seems almost nostalgic).  But here, you be the judge:


I certainly wish I could do what this cartoonist is doing when I'm teaching--I'm lucky if the students can read my writing whenever I put something up on the blackboard.  Oops, I mean whiteboard, all the chalk and slates are gone at Fordham University, replaced by markers and plastics.  What a stupid innovation, if you'll forgive me for being so blunt.  The markers dry out quickly and become useless, and what a waste!  With chalk, you could keep using it even when it was down to a nub too small to hold.  Of course, I don't miss the chalk dust, and the teacher's occupational hazard of getting chalk all over your rear end and back.  But whiteboards are a case where technological innovation does nothing to improve what we're doing, and may even have made things worse!  OK, rant complete.

As for the presentation, the sponsor, RSA, is the Royal Society for the encouragement of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce, a delightful name for an association (while, as an American, I have no use for royalty per se, I do wish we had royal societies here, it just sounds cool!). The RSA are located just behind the Strand in Westminster, London, for all you anglophiles out there (note that here in the US we would say that the RSA is, but given the subject, I thought I'd use the British usage).  The lecture itself is clear and reasonable, but strikes me as fairly obvious, or at least it ought to be.  

When I used to teach the basic communication course, textbooks typically included a chapter on organizational communication, and listed the three main perspectives on organizational behavior:  scientific management, which is concerned with the efficiency of operations (and relates to the simple task category discussed in this video); human relations, which is concerned with the motivation of individuals working within organizations, including their need for autonomy, satisfaction, and self-actualization (which relates to the main focus of this video); and systems, which looks at the organization in an organic fashion.

Perhaps I am being too critical, though, as I have been surprised on many occasions by how poorly people function in, and more so how poorly they understand organizations.  But that is a topic for another day, and another post.  For now, I'll just say that when it comes to the comics medium, I am indeed drawn to it.


Understanding the Comics Medium

My former MA student Mike Plugh, (who is about to embark on his doctoral work in the fall, congratulations again, Mike!), brought this video to my attention, and it's certainly worth including here on Blog Time Passing for a number of reasons.  While I haven't really gotten much into the subject, the medium of comics (as in comic strips and comic books) has come up here on occasion, and I have admitted to the fact that I have been reading comics all my life (see, for example, my post from a few years ago, More Conversations).

I've also noted that I think that Scott McCloud's Understanding Comics, a nonfictional, philosophical examination of the comics medium rendered in graphic novel format, is an excellent addition to the media ecology literature, and I've used it in graduate classes on a number of occasions.  The two sequels to Understanding Comics, Reinventing Comics, and Making Comics, are not quite as good as the first, but still interesting, and worth reading if you're at all interested in the medium, or visual communication in general.  The sequels also get into the impact and potential of digital technologies, which makes them relevant to the study of new media as well, and the third volume, Making Comics, is especially relevant to new media scholars.

So here is Scott McCloud giving one of those TED talks.  The opening, biographical presentation may not seem all that relevant to some, although he does bring it back into play at the end, and the overall theme of vision carries through the entire talk.





The name McCloud is certainly close enough to McLuhan to generate a sense of connection between the two, and McLuhan is his main media ecological influence, as you can tell by this presentation.  But there's also a subtle connection to general semantics as he claims a scientific orientation, and talks about abstracting, albeit in terms of images and visual communication, another example of how the concept of level of abstracting needs to be supplemented by the idea of mode of abstracting (see my previous posts, Language vs. Speech and Art, Abstracting, and Autism).  What he presents here really only gives you a taste of what's in Understanding Comics, however.

What stands out about this presentation, though, is his demonstration of the potential of digital, online comics, at the end of the talk, particularly in relation to, and as an alternative to hypertext.  The examples he gives are all from other comics creators, but you can find some of his own experiments on his website, http://scottmccloud.com, under the menu item of Webcomics. 

The idea of the screen as a window that reveals a fraction of a larger image, one that requires you to navigate through the terrain, the environment, is not unique to this particular art form (it's pretty basic in video games, after all, and in anything that requires a scroll bar for that matter, including basic word processing).  In fact, it's fairly intrinsic to digital media, but provides an invigorating boost when applied to comics, as can be seen from the examples he shows, and the ones he included on his site.

I have gone to his website and shown students some of this Webcomics in various new media classes I've taught where we've covered the topic of form, generally as a supplement to discussions of hypertext (so I was pleased to see him represent the digital comics in that context as well as in this talk).  One basic point in media ecology, going back to McLuhan, is that when new technologies are introduced, people try to use them to do the same old things they were doing with the old technologies, not recognizing their true potential; McLuhan argued that it takes artists (comics artists included) to probe the boundaries and uncover the possibilities of any new medium.

The one step McCloud has yet to take, at least as far as this video and his books are concerned, is to discuss the comics medium as an environment, an environment that becomes all the more visible, and dynamic, in this new, digital form.  What we need is a media ecology of comics!  Right, Mike?